Trump Fights Ruling That He Can’t Block Twitter Users
August 23, 2019, 8:10 PM
President Donald Trump is challenging a federal appeals court decision that ruled he violated the U.S. Constitution by blocking people whose views he disliked from his Twitter account.
In court papers filed late Friday by the U.S. Justice Department, Trump sought a rehearing by the full 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in New York, calling the 3-0 decision “fundamentally misconceived.”
Trump has more than 63 million followers on Twitter, and often uses his account to make significant announcements, including Friday when his tweets about trade with China sent U.S. stock and oil prices down sharply.
Lower court ruling upheld
The three-judge panel last month upheld a May 2018 lower court ruling that forced Trump to unblock several dozen followers.
Twitter Inc. and the White House did not immediately comment.
In the appellate court ruling, Circuit Judge Barrington Parker wrote, “the First Amendment does not permit a public official who utilizes a social media account for all manner of official purposes to exclude persons from an otherwise-open online dialog because they expressed views with which the official disagrees.”
White House social media director Dan Scavino, who was also a defendant, is also challenging the appeals court ruling.
The Justice Department court filing Friday warned that if the appeals court ruling was upheld, that “public officials who address matters relating to their public office on personal accounts will run the risk that every action taken on that account will be state action subject to constitutional scrutiny.”
'Official, state-run account'
Parker, however, had said Trump’s account bears “all the trappings of an official, state-run account” and is “one of the White House’s main vehicles for conducting official business.”
Trump has made his @RealDonaldTrump account, which he opened in 2009, a central and controversial part of his presidency, using it to promote his agenda and attack critics.
His blocking of critics was challenged by the Knight First Amendment Institute at Columbia University, as well as seven Twitter users he had blocked.
AMAC SAVING THE NATION - BOOTCAMP FOR PATRIOTS SPECIAL6-19-26 at 12NOON ET.
JOIN ERIC BOLLING LIVE AT THE REDNECK RIVIERA IN NASHVILLE ON JUNE 26TH
If you're in the greater Nashville area, you won't want to miss this!
Join Eric Bolling LIVE this Friday, June 26, for Main Street America Live: Redneck Riviera from John Rich's legendary Nashville venue. Meet fellow patriots, enjoy live music, and be part of our live audience for this special Summer Series event.
🎟️ Tickets are limited and going fast: https://bit.ly/4a46yYp
CELEBRATE FREEDOM - LIVE BROADCAST CONCERT EXPERIENCE
We invite you to join us for "Celebrate Freedom" Live Broadcast Experience at Marty B'S in Texas this Memorial Day weekend. Special performances by Natasha Owens, DPAK, and Celeste Kellogg. The event begins at 5PM ET. only here on Real America's Voice! Sponsored by: PreBorn and Patriot Mobile.
REDEDICATE 250 — A NATIONAL JUBILEE OF PRAYER PRAISE AND THANKSGIVING
WATCH SECURING AMERICA WITH FRANK GAFFNEY M-F AT 5AM ET.
WATCH DAYBREAK WITH STEVE & IVEY GRUBER M-F FROM 6-8AM ET.
WATCH THE AMERICAN SUNRISE SHOW M-F AT 8AM ET.
WATCH THE LATEST EDITION OF WAR ROOM WITH STEVE BANNON
WATCH THE CHARLIE KIRK SHOW M-F AT 12NOON ET.
HUMAN EVENTS DAILYWITH JACK POSOBIEC
CATCH THE LATEST AMERICA'S VOICE LIVE SHOW
JOIN THE ERIC BOLLING SHOW M-F AT 4PM ET.
WATCH JUST THE NEWS - NO NOISE
THE GRANT STINCHFIELD TONIGHT SHOW M-F AT 7PM ET.
WATCH LIVE FROM STUDIO 6B M-F AT 8PM ET.
WATCH AMERICA SPEAKS WITH WAYNE ALLYN ROOT
TURNING POINT TONIGHT SHOW M-TH AT 10PM ET.
CATCH THE AFTER HOURS SHOW WITH ALEX STEIN M-F AT 11PM ET.
WATCH THIS WEEK'S BREAKING POINT WITH DAVID ZERE
CATCH THE ROYCE WHITE SHOW EVERY SATURDAY MORNING AT 9AM ET.
WATCH AMERICA'S TOP 10 COUNTDOWN SATURDAYS AT12 NOON ET.
ON THE INSIDE WITH JAMES O'KEEFE SATURDAYS AT 1PM ET.
WATCH RINGSIDE POLITICS WITH JEFF CROUERE - SATURDAY'S AT 2PM ET.
JOIN THE TED NUGENT SPIRIT CAMPFIRE SHOW SATURDAYS AT 3PM ET.
WATCH THE CASE FOR AMERICA EVERY SATURDAY AT 4PM ET.
WATCH THE CASE FOR AMERICA WITH TRENISS EVANS - SATURDAYS AT 4PM ET.
LAST CALL WITH MIKE CRISPI - SATURDAYS AT 8PM ET.
WATCH THE LATEST COWBOY LOGIC BARN PARTY
WATCH AMERICA SHINES WITH AUBREY SHINES SUNDAYS AT 6AM ET.
WATCH GET REAL WITH DAVID DESROSIERS - TUNE IN SUNDAYS AT 3PM ET.
WATCH THE SHEMANE NUGENT FAITH & FREEDOM SHOW SUNDAYS AT 2PM ET.
MEDIA EXPOSED WITH ADAM WEISS SUNDAYS AT 6PM ET.
WATCH SMACK DOWN WITH DARREL SCOTT - SUNDAY'S AT 7PM ET.
CATCH THE LATEST EPISODE OF LAW & BORDER WITH BEN BERGQUAM
CHECK OUT THE RIGHT NEWS SHOW WITH JAVIER NEGRE SUNDAYS AT 8PM ET.